Wednesday, 9 July 2014

Quarterly Update



Asset
Bloomberg Ticker


H&T
HAT LN
15.0%

AIG
AIG US
12.8%

Avesco
AVS LN
13.8%

Commerzbank
CBK GY
11.2%

Safestyle PLC
SFE LN
11.5%

Emeco Holdings
EHL ASX
13.9%

Hargreaves Services
HSP LN
9.1%

Dolphin Capital
DCI LN
5.9%

Alternative Asset Opportunities
TLI LN
5.8%

Plaza Centers
PLAZ LN
0.8%

GBP Cash

0.1%





Quarterly Return
Quarterly Benchmark Return

-7.80%
2.6625%


Return Since Inception
Benchmark Return since Inception
18.10%
24.9%


Annualised Return since Inception
Annualised Benchmark Return since Inception
11.70%
16.00%



This was a poor quarter for me, reversing much of my out performance of the first quarter.  Unfortunately large idiosyncratic fluctuations are the price one pays for running a concentrated portfolio.  If a few stocks take a dive, then the effect will be substantial.  The good news for me is that I think I understand the reason for the falls and I think the declines are temporary.
Emeco Holdings: Investors continue to shun stocks related to the mining sector amid the uncertainty around future prospects.  Yet the thesis remains the same.  The business will normalise to a lower level of assets and earnings in a few years, and large amounts of cash will be released.
Commerzbank seems relatively healthy to me.  The stock fell sharply yesterday on news of a fine that was less than 15% of what BNP incurred and was less than what was provisioned.  This quarter they've sold the majority of their Spanish Real Estate assets and there has been little other adverse news.  I believe the stock continues to live under the cloud of the ECB Financial Stability Review.  As one of the banks with the lowest capital levels, there is a belief that it may have to raise capital.  As it is priced for this, I don't see a capital raise as too much of a threat to long term returns and indeed it may hasten the return of the perception of strength.  Things will be a lot clearer by the end of the year.
Safestyle seems absurdly cheap to me.  It is priced at a P/FCF of around 10* and I believe it has suffered because the whole of the UK Small Cap has suffered, along with a swathe of IPOs.
AIG continues its grind higher and I believe this will not stop any time soon.  In the context of the US market and US large caps it must be one of the few value stocks still out there!  As long as it trades below book and stock is rebought I'll be happy.
Hargreaves Services was... an error. I was stupidly seduced by its optical cheapness and a write up I saw elsewhere.  While it has no doubt been hit by bad sentiment over the coal sector, and may be oversold, I fully admit to not fully understanding the business model and future prospects.  The recent profit warning it testimony to the poor quality of earnings.  This stock will struggle to ever achieve a premium multiple because any company operating in the coal sector will constantly have to adjust its business model to events.  There may be great riches to be made but will the market ever anticipate them? 
H&T is another stock where I have probably not sufficiently considered the potential for multiple expansion.  The exposure to gold prices will remain in investors' minds for a long time and it will always have a certain cloud hanging over it.  That said, I do expect the upcoming interims to show positive progress on  deleveraging, margins and revenues.  The payday loan industry is being squeezed and pawnbrokers may receive some collateral benefit.  In addition, Albemarle and Bond have gone bankrupt, been bought and dramatically reduced their estate of stores.  The collapse of the gold price will have hurt many of the pawnbrokers that have opened in the last few years and H&T have indicated that the opportunity will exist for bolt on acquisitions.  In short, there appear to be multiple ways that good things can happen to this stock.  Even typing that sentence, I remembered that there is a trend towards people using their tablets and other electrical devices as collateral.  These are often one of the most valuable possessions that someone owns and many more people own tablets that gold jewelry, I would asset.  Again, I eagerly await their interim financials.  http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-27035109     http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/141899d6-dcf6-11e3-ba13-00144feabdc0.html#axzz36yMLQMOr
Dolphin Capital is truly a slow burner.  But read last weekend's FT and its special report on Greece, which highlighted expected growth in the luxury hotels sector and record numbers of tourists in Greece.  Dolphin are the experts in this sector and I remain happy to own assets at far less than book value. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/cda98386-fd41-11e3-bc93-00144feab7de.html?siteedition=uk#axzz36yMLQMOr
This brings me to my recently initiated position in Avesco PLC.  I can take no credit for it, as it is the idea of Red Corner (http://quinzedix.blogspot.co.uk/2014/04/avesco-is-collection-ofbusinesses-that.html).  My investment priority is not to write a great blog or come up with great ideas.  It is to make as much money as possible, and so when I see a superior idea elsewhere I'm going to take it.  What I can add to his superb write up is that the interims have come out since, and they appear to make reality the thesis that growth Capex obscures the true earnings power of the business.  Market Cap is £21mln and trading profit (EBIT before restructuring) was £4.5mln in H1.  The management statement said all the right things, and they increased the dividend.  I am very happy to have this in my portfolio.
Finally, Alternative Asset Holdings (TLI): When I bought this stock I acknowledged that there was currency risk involved but was comfortable bearing this risk.  The USD has since fallen pretty much in a straight line against GBP, cancelling out growth in underlying NAV and a promising amounts of realisations.  The company recently announced that it would start distributing cash, via returns of capital.  While buybacks would be ideal as the long as it is trading well below NAV, I appreciate that it is probably hard to execute a buy back programme with a micro cap such as this.  So, going forward, we can expect regular returns of cash.  At some point, the market has to realise the attractions of this security.